Talk:Bandai Khalsa

Google search of:"Madho Das spent many years wandering with these Sadhus accumulating a tremendous amount of knowledge" does not yield copyright violation. see Google Search

Cannot detect any copyright violation here! Hari Singh 19:53, 31 March 2007 (EDT)

English and grammar

Bhai Sahib Lucky ji, It seems that answers to the many questions you pose are obvious.

I have read accounts of the foreigners who observed the events at the time. They record that Banda himself for his arrest and torture, the result of his hubris, of taking things way beyond the mission that Guru Gobind Singh had intended.

Like Aurangzeb, he had apparently proved the old saying that power corrupts and that wanton killing (as your page records) gives rise to hate, anger and vengeance. If I remember correctly, there was never any attempts to wipe the Sikhs out during the days of the Gurus. When Guru Arjan was murdered - n one sent troops to destroy Amritsar or set bounties on Sikh heads (i.e. no one tried to wipe the Sikh religion out.)

Even after the sacking of Amritsar and the death of his mother, father and sons, Guru Gobind Singh never sought revenge, and indeed helped Aurangzeb's son to gain his throne. As someone here once said - he never fought a war to build an earthly kingdom or gain an empire. He saw the need of defense, but violence to control others was not his mission.

Allanwalla ji

Those answers are to settle down these question to little extent but those are not moth tape answers. These questions were asked by those people whose ancestors were staying with gurus, who were baptized by guru themselves. Those ancestors told whole stories of guru and those events comes generations by generations to them. i met such persons, i told them to write book and expose truth but these guys don't take any tension and reply """Sach nu dabya rehan do"", they have many many many valid points against banda. I just have 2 - 3 out of them. I have positive study of Banda. rite now i am concentrating on events which are quite confusing. if 5 authors are writing books one says bandai khalsa emerge, other says some started following banda singh as guru...how?

Moreover Wazir khan of sirhind have done vey wrong with sikhs and was doing so guru send banda to give him a reply but he did not know that banda will do like this.

Some people say guru was not bad judge. but Guru Sahib was decieved many times by these type of people for example Majhail Sikhs(Though 40 returned after), Gangu, Nirmala Sikh(Preached Hinduism), Aurangzed Quran Shapat, Pathans at Bhangani etc.

(Lucky 04:31, 10 May 2010 (UTC))