User talk:Ads2bad22

From SikhiWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search

Deletion of article "Guru Nanak in Mecca"

You said:

THE ARTICLE MENTIONED THAT GURU NANAK TALKED TO THE MULLAHS ETC ABOUT WHAT THE FAITH WAS ABOUT AND STUFF aND THAT ALSO HE TALKED TO THE QAZIS TO MOVE HIS FEET WHERE GODS HOUSE WASNT THERE IT MEANS THAT YOUR GURU NANAK KNEW ARABIC IS IT OR THAT The ARABS KNEW PUNJABI OR HINDI??? THIS ARTICLE IS SO FAKE IT MAKES NO SENSE... THERE IS NO HISTORICAL EVIDENCE APART FROM THE WORDS OF SOME SIKHS MOUTH WHO WERENT EVEN THERE...

COMMON LOGICALLY HOW CAN THE WHOLE KABBA TURN? for me its fabricated... and ya if u have an answer than pls do reply back... most probably you guys are gonna delete my comment n e ways


Reply:

By deleting the article you have violated rules of this Wiki and so you have been blocked from this site.

Obviously, you have not taken any time to learn about Guru Nanak. The Guru was fluent in many languages. Further he was travelling with Bhai Mardana who was a Muslim with knowledge of the language of the Koran and probably able to communicate with the natives.

When we travel to Mecca now, we can communicate there in many languages because people from many background are there; you don't need to speak in Arabic to get on. The situation was not totally different in the 1500's; people from many countries were there and able to help with translation if needed. Also, Farsi was commonly spoke in India and I am sure the Qazi would have understood Farsi which was the dominant language of Persia.

No Muslims of that time has raised any objections to the sakhi of this visit. The Sakhi was a famous one and well known; Bhai Mardana and other Muslim friends of the Sikhs agreed with the record, which dates back to the 1500s and 1600s - Just like the sakhi of Panja Sahib. You would probably say that even that also did not happen!!! And what about Namdev and the temple in South India; did that not turn? see Bhagat Namdev at the Temple.

How can the holy Kabba turn? Explain to me how a human being (Guru Nanak) stop a rock weighing many tons with one hand, then I will explain how the holy Kabba can turn.

And finally you are wrong again about us deleting your post. It is here with a reply. Regards, Hari Singhtalk 23:41, 13 October 2009 (UTC)