Talk:Vivekananda and Ramakrishna on Sikhism

The article which had little to do about the two men's views concerning Sikhi was really a quite disgusting attack on Vivekananda.

It would have been better to have been titled -- The Disgusting life of Vivekananda. Their are many who would be deeply hurt by the article, if I saw anyone writing such trash about the Sikh Gurus I would be outragged.

The recent edit turned into another article that had nothing to do with the topic, as it was only a flowery bio on Vivekananda.

So I gave minimal facts (history) on both men for strangers who might come across the page unaware of who Vivekananda was.

I also tried to make sense of the few sentences that had to do with the stated topic.

The clearly hate filled page, not something the Gurus would have been proud to see here, was not even signed by the author.

The sentences that do have to do with the topic are not cited (i.e. we do not know where these came from -- were they invented by the writers mind (his/her ORIGINAL RESEARCH or are they in the man's writing.

Please if my efforts have left out something important out - please add it back in. Are all Hindus are out to destroy Sikhi, (clearly there are those who believe that Sikhi is a sect of Hinduism, but this page is about what these two men thought about Sikhism.

Also I think the title would be better as Vivekananda and Ramakrishna on Sikhism.

Allenwalla 13:54, 19 February 2010 (UTC)