Talk:Guru Granth Sahib's guidance for Muslims

It seems shameful for someone to claim that even Guru Nanak and all those Sikhs including each Guru and all their followers before Guru Hargobind and the thousands of Sikhs who died before Guru Gobing Singh gave birth to the Khalsa had /have no right to be called Sikhs. Did the sixth, seventh or eighth Guru carry weapons or even Guru Tegh Bahadur, thought he did use a Shastar in his childhood-- he did not use a weapon in his latter life. For someone to try to prove that Sikhs who may cut their hair or not carry weapons or never did are not Sikhs is ridiculous--to say they may not call themselves Khalsa would be more appropriate. Allenwalla 01:11, 22 January 2009 (UTC)

So out of ten Gurus only one advocates weapons in a time when they were essential condemns all others to a lesser stature-as not Sikhs?