Talk:Second battle of Chamkaur Sahib

From SikhiWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search

members, pls don't touch these articles related to battle of chamkaur, i am working on it thanks, may be i have to delete something from it

Noticed message

This article is creating history with errors added in at will - since the only account of the battle is the gurus own letter, the Zafarnama, which is also in question. Should we not trust the words of the Guru who makes no mention of Wazir Khan's being there. All to often articles here have taken on the look of comic books were we just add in what we wish had happened. As the articles once penned become epic i suggest we stick to what has been written. Here the Haveli usually reported to have belonged to two brothers who argued over Guru moving from a grove where he had camped, has now turned into the haveli being owned by a man who came to offer it, no mention of the brother mentioned in many other stories. When we magically add details that differ are we not creating lies? Should we not stick to the historic accounts?

So sorry that i have corrected the English, you may revert the story please as i didn't see your unsigned request until i added these notes. Allenwalla 09:57, 21 December 2009 (UTC)