Talk:Iron Clad Soldiers: Difference between revisions
From SikhiWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Akal jsingh (talk | contribs) (New page: I have not liked this so called 'Saakhi'. Please.. let us not start inventing Saakhis by ourselves, and put Rani Mukherjee pictures on top. Please respect your culture and understand wha...) |
Hari singh (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
Please respect your culture and understand what a Saakhi is. It is not a piece of fiction. | Please respect your culture and understand what a Saakhi is. It is not a piece of fiction. | ||
==reply== | |||
As you will see this article is based on the original which is [http://www.gurmatps.org/index.html?other_books/naamnet/03_01_iron_clad_soldiers at: www.gurmatps.org - here]. | |||
I am sorry that you did not like the article. You mention several things and I will deal with them separately. Please note the following: | |||
*1: '''[[Sakhi]] invented by SikhiWiki''': This [[Sakhi]] was not "invented by us" as already mentioned as it came from another respected Sikhi site. I would suggest you contact them if you have any comments about the content of the page. | |||
*2: '''Putting a picture''': Putting a picture on the page to depict some of the points mentioned in the sakhi does not amount to "inventing". You will see many picture or movies depicting sakhis in our culture - ''Ucha Dar Babbe 'Nanak' Da'', [[Baba Deep Singh]], etc. These are not regarded as inventions but an alternative avenue for the representation of the sakhi in another media, art-form, language of communication for exchange of ideas. | |||
*3: '''No respect for our culture''': We at [[SikhiWiki]] do care about and respect our culture and hence have spent many thousands of hours of [[Sewa]] to create this site. If we did not care, then we would have done nothing or very little like the "silent majority" who take little or no part in the spreading of our literature and culture. | |||
If you have any further factual point regarding this work, or you wish to point out some other material deficiency in the article which disturbs you, then please let us know so that we can pass these on to www.gurmatps.org. | |||
Kind regards, [[user:hari singh|Hari Singh]]<sup>[[User talk:Hari singh|talk]]</sup> 10:51, 17 March 2009 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 04:51, 17 March 2009
I have not liked this so called 'Saakhi'. Please.. let us not start inventing Saakhis by ourselves, and put Rani Mukherjee pictures on top.
Please respect your culture and understand what a Saakhi is. It is not a piece of fiction.
reply
As you will see this article is based on the original which is at: www.gurmatps.org - here.
I am sorry that you did not like the article. You mention several things and I will deal with them separately. Please note the following:
- 1: Sakhi invented by SikhiWiki: This Sakhi was not "invented by us" as already mentioned as it came from another respected Sikhi site. I would suggest you contact them if you have any comments about the content of the page.
- 2: Putting a picture: Putting a picture on the page to depict some of the points mentioned in the sakhi does not amount to "inventing". You will see many picture or movies depicting sakhis in our culture - Ucha Dar Babbe 'Nanak' Da, Baba Deep Singh, etc. These are not regarded as inventions but an alternative avenue for the representation of the sakhi in another media, art-form, language of communication for exchange of ideas.
- 3: No respect for our culture: We at SikhiWiki do care about and respect our culture and hence have spent many thousands of hours of Sewa to create this site. If we did not care, then we would have done nothing or very little like the "silent majority" who take little or no part in the spreading of our literature and culture.
If you have any further factual point regarding this work, or you wish to point out some other material deficiency in the article which disturbs you, then please let us know so that we can pass these on to www.gurmatps.org.
Kind regards, Hari Singhtalk 10:51, 17 March 2009 (UTC)
