Talk:Guru Nanak: Mecca was Vedic

I guess this is making fun of Baig, thinly vailed commentary of a man who must justify his religion by finding-leaves in a teacup or a reference , no one else sees, in old vedic writings.

As ridiculous as the Muslin writer who was claiming Guru Nanak as a Musalman. And then to give him praise as in… - Fortunately there are scholars who know better, and one of them is Mirza Afzal Baig of Jamaat-i-Islami.

From where / in what writings does Goshati find the actual words of Guru Nanak as spoken in Makkah, as he reports in his Makke-Madine or (Makkah-Medina) are these actual words in the Janamsĝkhīs. Guru Nanak would have been well aware of Mohamet's history and the history of Islam from his childhood and adult associations with musalmen. I do not think that he would ever deride anothers religion by saying to a Muslim of their Rasul--He floated some sort of a creed, and taught it.

Allenwalla 20:57, 23 January 2008 (MST) where i am from floated is as one might say derogatory and negative for things that are floated — sink. As in the stock market "he foated bonds" refer to junk bonds that end up as trash.