User talk:Ravinderkaler: Difference between revisions
Hari singh (talk | contribs) (New page: <div class="usermessage" style="font-size: 90%;font-weight:normal;"> left|100px '''Hello, Sat Sri Akal, W.K.W.F, {{BASEPAGENAME}} Ji!''' A very warm welcome fro...) |
Hari singh (talk | contribs) |
||
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
With [[Waheguru]]'s kirpa, may you always remain in [[Chardi kala]]. Many thanks, [[User:Hari singh|Hari Singh]] 10:38, 11 April 2007 (EDT) </div> | With [[Waheguru]]'s kirpa, may you always remain in [[Chardi kala]]. Many thanks, [[User:Hari singh|Hari Singh]] 10:38, 11 April 2007 (EDT) </div> | ||
== [[Vegetarianism]] == | |||
Many thanks for your contribution to the above article. However, I have added a query on this quotation ''"...yet Guru Gobind Singh Ji killed a goat to show the blood when he "cut off" Daya Singh Ji's head"''. | |||
I do not believe that it is correct to assume that a goat was slaughter by Guru Sahib. Apparently, the event took place in a tent - So we have to assume that there is no historic evidence of what happened inside the tent. Also, I agree with you that Guru ji would not have killed a goat if another less cruel possibility was available. And I can think of many other ways of displaying a bloody sword if that is what is required. Speak to any theatrical producer and you will get hundreds of options. However, I don't think Guru ji was doing a theatrical display though – but that is another story for another time! --[[User:Hari singh|Hari Singh]] 11:17, 11 April 2007 (EDT) |
Revision as of 09:17, 11 April 2007
Vegetarianism
Many thanks for your contribution to the above article. However, I have added a query on this quotation "...yet Guru Gobind Singh Ji killed a goat to show the blood when he "cut off" Daya Singh Ji's head".
I do not believe that it is correct to assume that a goat was slaughter by Guru Sahib. Apparently, the event took place in a tent - So we have to assume that there is no historic evidence of what happened inside the tent. Also, I agree with you that Guru ji would not have killed a goat if another less cruel possibility was available. And I can think of many other ways of displaying a bloody sword if that is what is required. Speak to any theatrical producer and you will get hundreds of options. However, I don't think Guru ji was doing a theatrical display though – but that is another story for another time! --Hari Singh 11:17, 11 April 2007 (EDT)