Talk:Guru Nanak in Mecca

Also might i add. That the Kaaba does not move. This is just a made up fairytale!

And many of the things stated in this article is 100% FALSE!

_________________________________________________________

Isn't this proof that Guru Nanak was a Muslim?

I mean ONLY Muslims are alowed in the city of Mecca!http://islam.about.com/od/hajj/f/mecca.htm

So if Guru Nanak was NOT a muslim. Then how could he enter the city of Mecca?

So then how did Richard Burton get in?

__________________________________________________________

Clarification of edit: Hajjis carrying Koran under their arms

Hajjis do not typically carry a Koran under their arms.

Hajjis carrying the Koran under their arms

Interesting point! - I do not have any personal experience about this but - I wonder if in those days, 500 years ago, the Hajjis did carry the Koran with them so that they could recite it whenever required. Remember that they did not have huge public address (PA) system then. I will check more on this fact before we can really determine for sure -but I assume that you have checked this matter with someone who does have real experience of being a hajji. --Hari Singh 18:02, 2 July 2006 (Central Daylight Time)

Well waana add

Guru did dress up like a Muslim but in book were not the kuranic verses but allagedly Gurbani. Some are in Guru Granth Sahib ji but some like Nasihat Nammah is not in there.

Certainly Surah 10:4 which says to treat unbelievers (anyone not Muslim) to a bath in boiling water, a favorite torture used on several Sikhs, is only in the Quran.